Sustainable energy

This article is about a concept related to renewable energy, of which sustainable energy is a superset.

Sustainable energy sources are energy sources which are not expected to be depleted in a timeframe relevant to the human race, and which therefore contribute to the sustainability of all species. This concept is termed sustainability. An additional criterion for strict sustainability, useful for short- and medium term decisions is social and political sustainability of an energy technology.

Sustainable energy sources are most often regarded as including all renewable sources, such as solar power, wind power, wave power, geothermal power, tidal power, and others.

Fission power and fusion power meet the definition of sustainability, but there is controversy over whether or not they should be regarded as sustainable for social and political reasons.

Renewable energy sources

Wind power is one of the most environmentally friendly sources of renewable energy

Main article: renewable energy

Renewable energy sources are those whose stock is rapidly replenished by natural processes, and which aren't expected to be depleted within the lifetime of the human species.

The well-known renewable energy options can be classified by the natural process that provides their energy:

Direct solar energy:

• Solar cells use semiconductors to directly convert sunlight into electricity. Primary challenges with their use are low efficiency, energy-intensive manufacture, and power variability due to weather and nightfall.
• Solar thermal plants use concentrated sunlight as a heat source to power a heat engine which generates electricity. Primary challenges with their use are manufacture and maintenance of large mirror arrays and power variability due to weather and nightfall.
• Solar updraft tower plants use sunlight to heat a contained mass of air, setting up convection currents that cause air to exit through a chimney from which power is tapped. Primary challenges with their use are low efficiency, construction and maintenance of the large structures required, and power variability due to weather (a Solar updraft tower has enough heat capacity to function through night).

Indirect solar energy:

• Ocean thermal energy conversion uses the temperature difference between the warmer surface of the ocean and the cooler lower depths to drive a heat engine. The primary challenges with ocean thermal energy conversion's use are low efficiency and the construction and maintenance of large strutures in a sea environment.
• Wind power uses wind turbines to draw energy from large-scale motion of air. The primary challenges with wind power's use are the large areas required to produce useful amounts of electricity, and power variability due to weather.
• Hydroelectricity uses dams to draw energy from the flow of water from high-altitude areas to areas with lower altitudes. Primary challenges with hydroelectricity's use are the environmental damage caused by the construction of dams, and the scarcity of remaining sites for power generation.
• Wave power uses floats to extract mechanical energy from the motion of waves. Primary challenges with wave power's use are the large areas required to produce useful amounts of electricity, and disruption of coastal environments.
• Biofuel uses products of plants, animals, or bacteria to provide fuels that can be used in a manner similar to fossil fuels. The primary challenge with biofuel's use is the availability of suitable feedstock in sufficient quantity for large-scale adoption.

Radioactive decay within the Earth:

• Geothermal power uses the temperature difference between the earth's surface and its interior to drive a heat engine, generally at a location such as a hot spring where the heat has been transported most of the way to the surface by natural processes. The primary challenge with geothermal power's use is low power generation efficiency for most sites.

Rotation of the Earth:

• Tidal power uses dams to draw energy from the changes in water height due to tides produced by the gravitational influences of the moon and sun as Earth rotates. The primary challenges with tidal power's use are the large area required to produce useful amounts of electricity, and disruption of coastal environments.

Processes powered by solar energy will be renewed for as long as the sun remains on the main sequence (approximately 5 billion years). Processes powered by radioactive decay within the Earth will be renewed for time comparable to the half-life of uranium 238 (4.5 billion years) and thorium 232 (14 billion years). Processes powered by the Earth's rotation will last until the Earth becomes tidally locked to the Sun (though tidal acceleration would eject the moon from Earth orbit earlier). Both of these would take longer than the expected lifetime of the sun to occur.

Sustainable sources not considered renewable

Sustainable energy sources that aren't renewable are those whose stock is not replenished, but for which the presently available stocks are expected to last for as long as human civilization cares to use them.

These energy sources are derived from nuclear energy, as other forms of stored energy found on Earth do not have sufficient energy density to supply humanity indefinitely.

• Fission power uses the nuclear fission of heavy elements to release energy that drives a heat engine. Primary challenges with the use of fission power are the production of small quantities of highly-radioactive waste in the form of spent fuel, larger quantities of less-radioactive waste in the form of activated structural material, and (for use as a long-term power source) the need to perform intensive processing of highly-radioactive fuel bundles, both to reclaim unused fuel in spent fuel rods, and to reclaim plutonium 239 and uranium 233 that have been bred from uranium 238 and thorium 232, respectively.

• Fusion power uses the nuclear fusion of isotopes of hydrogen to release energy that drives a heat engine. Primary challenges with the use of fusion power are that the technology required to build a useful fusion power plant are still under development, and that substantial quantities of radioactive waste in the form of activated structural material is produced.

Fission power's long-term sustainability depends on the amount of uranium and thorium that is available to be mined. Estimates for fuel reserves vary widely, but if breeder reactors and fuel reprocessing are assumed, tend to be tens of thousands of years or longer (uranium is approximately as common in Earth's crust as tin or zinc (2 ppm), and thorium as common as lead (6 ppm)).

Fusion power's long-term sustainability depends on the amount of lithium that is available to be mined (for deuterium-tritium fusion), or the amount of deuterium available in seawater (for deuterium-deuterium fusion). Lithium is a reasonably common component of Earth's crust, being about 10 times as common as thorium (65 ppm). Deuterium (a hydrogen isotope) occurs wherever hydrogen is found (principally in water), at about 150 ppm. As it can be extracted easily from seawater, economically viable reserves of deuterium are for practical purposes unlimited.

Technical sustainability of nuclear power

Discussions are re-emerging on proper classification of nuclear energy under such umbrella terms as "renewable" and "sustainable" These attributes bring moral gains or eligibility for development aid under various jurisdictions.

The primary argument in favor of "renewable" status is the relatively inexhaustible supply of fuel available (uranium and thorium for fission or hydrogen for fusion). See also: Renewable energy, Nuclear power section.

Proponents, such as environmentalists James Lovelock, Patrick Moore (Greenpeace co-founder), Stewart Brand (creator of The Whole Earth Catalog), and Norris McDonald (president of the AAEA), also claim that nuclear power is at least as environmentally friendly as traditional sources of renewable energy, making it the best future solution to global warming and the world's growing need for energy. They note that nuclear power plants produce little carbon dioxide emissions and claim that the radioactive waste produced is minimal and well-contained, especially compared to fossil fuels. ^[1]

In 2001, professors Jan Willem Storm van Leeuwen and Philip Smith released a study which argued that, though nuclear plants don't produce any CO₂ directly, the energy required for the rest of the nuclear fuel cycle (uranium mining, enrichment, transportation) and power plant life cycle (construction, maintenance, decommissioning) leads to significant carbon dioxide emissions, especially as usage of lower-grade uranium becomes necessary.^[2] In 2000, however, Frans H. Koch of the International Energy Agency reported that, although it is correct that the nuclear life cycle produces greenhouse gases, these emissions are actually less than the life cycle emissions of other renewables, like solar and wind, and drastically less than fossil fuels.^[3]

Political sustainability of nuclear power

Some critics of nuclear energy argue that deployment of nuclear reactors in many countries would accelerate the proliferation of nuclear weapons technology that has many links with civilian use of nuclear materials. Some nuclear reactors (especially heavy water moderated reactors) create the materials necessary for these weapons.

The issue of fuel reprocessing and/or long-term repository of nuclear waste materials also remains contentious. Very few coutries have developed waste depositories for high-level radioactive waste (see: Yucca Mountain Repository USA; Gorleben Germany; Forsmark, Sweden).

Due to oposition to nuclear power many countries (Austria, Italy, Sweden, Germany) have effectively banned further development of nuclear energy; a clear lack of political sustainability under present conditions.

References

1. ^ Prominent Environmentalists Support Nuclear Energy
2. ^ Nuclear Power, The Energy Balance - Chapter 1 - The CO₂-emission of the nuclear life-cycle
3. ^ "Hydropower-Internalised Costs and Externalised Benefits"; Frans H. Koch; International Energy Agency (IEA)-Implementing Agreement for Hydropower Technologies and Programmes; Ottawa, Canada, 2000

See also

• Renewable energy
• Sustainability
• List of energy topics
• Energy conservation
• Green energy
• Green tax shift
• Nuclear power phase-out
• Oil phase-out in Sweden

External links

• CleanEnergyTalk - A community dedicated to education about clean & renewable energies and technologies, and their future in society.

Sustainability and Development of Energy   Edit Conversion | Development and Use | Sustainable Energy | Conservation | Transportation

Categories

Find

Find